← All articles
TechniqueTroubleshooting

The Macaron Troubleshooting Guide

Cracked tops, hollow shells, no feet? Find the symptom, find the cause, fix the next batch. A field guide from years of trial and error.

Macarons have a reputation for being fussy, and it’s partly earned. There are only four ingredients, so every small thing shows: a few extra folds of the batter, an oven that runs hot, a humid afternoon. The good news is that macarons are also honest. Every flaw on a shell points back to a cause, and once you can read the clues, you can fix it.

I approach a failed batch the way I’d approach a bug: reproduce it, change one variable at a time, and write down what happened. Use the table below to find your symptom, then work through the likely causes from top to bottom.

Quick diagnosis

Problem Likely cause Fix
Cracked tops Air trapped in the batter; shells not rested long enough to form a skin; oven too hot or too much heat from below. Rap the tray firmly on the counter after piping and pop surface bubbles with a toothpick. Rest until the tops feel dry, not tacky. Check the real oven temperature, and try doubling up the baking trays to soften bottom heat.
No feet Overmixed batter; no skin formed (often humidity); oven too cool; a meringue that was too soft. Stop folding a little earlier. Rest the shells until they’re dry to a light touch. Verify the oven with a thermometer. Whip the meringue to stiff, glossy peaks.
Hollow shells Overwhipped (dry, clumpy) meringue; oven too hot so the shell rises before the inside sets; underbaking. Whip until stiff and glossy, then stop. Lower the temperature slightly and bake a little longer. Bake until the shells don’t wobble on their feet when nudged.
Lopsided or spread feet Uneven oven heat or a strong convection fan; piping at an angle; runny batter; a warped tray. Pipe straight down with the bag at 90°. Rotate the tray halfway through. Turn the fan down or off if you can. Use a heavy, flat tray.
Sticky bottoms Underbaked; shells removed from the mat while still warm. Add 1–2 minutes to the bake. Let the shells cool completely on the mat before peeling them off.
Wrinkly or bumpy tops Coarse or oily almond flour; dry ingredients not sifted; too much liquid coloring; batter under- or overmixed. Pulse the almond flour with the powdered sugar briefly and sift. Use gel or powder color, not liquid. Do the macaronage test (below).
Browned shells Oven too hot; rack too high; baked too long. Lower the temperature. Bake on the middle rack. Slide an empty tray onto the rack above to shield pale colors.
Spreading or flat shells Overmixed batter; a weak meringue; extra liquid from coloring or flavoring. Stop folding when the batter ribbons (see the test below). Whip to stiff peaks. Flavor the filling, not the shell.
Grainy filling Sugar that hasn’t dissolved; butter too cold so the buttercream breaks; a ganache that split. Use powdered sugar, or a Swiss meringue buttercream heated until the sugar dissolves. Keep the butter at soft room temperature. Re-whip a broken buttercream after warming the bowl gently.

Rule of thumb: if a whole tray fails the same way, look at the batter. If only some shells fail, or only one side of the tray does, look at the oven.

Get an oven thermometer

If you buy one thing, make it a $10 oven thermometer. Home ovens are often off by 10–25°F, and many swing up and down as the element cycles. Macarons usually bake somewhere around 285–320°F (140–160°C) for 12–18 minutes. That window is narrow enough that a “300°F” oven that’s really at 325°F turns out a completely different cookie.

Put the thermometer where the tray sits, preheat for at least 20 minutes, and trust the thermometer over the dial. Then adjust one thing at a time: temperature first, then time.

Aging egg whites

Many recipes call for “aged” whites. You separate them a day or two ahead, cover them, and keep them in the fridge. A little moisture evaporates and the whites become slightly more fluid, and some bakers find they whip more reliably. It isn’t magic, and plenty of good macarons are made with fresh whites, especially with Italian meringue.

What really matters:

  • Room temperature. Take the whites out of the fridge 1–2 hours before you whip them.
  • No fat at all. A trace of yolk or a greasy bowl will stop the meringue from reaching full volume. Wipe the bowl and whisk with a little vinegar or lemon juice.
  • Weigh them. “Three egg whites” can be anywhere from 85 to 110 g. Use a scale for everything.

Humidity in South Florida

Here, humidity is the variable you can’t skip. Shells need to form a dry skin before baking, and on a muggy day that can take an hour or more, or not happen at all. When the shells can’t dry, they crack and lose their feet.

  • Run the AC (or a dehumidifier) in the kitchen while you bake. A cool, dry room makes a real difference.
  • Avoid baking right after mopping, boiling pasta or running the dishwasher. Steam is the enemy.
  • Consider Italian meringue. The hot sugar syrup makes a more stable batter that copes better with humidity.
  • A pinch of egg-white powder (a few grams added to the sugar) helps some bakers stabilize the meringue on humid days.
  • Store shells airtight. Unfilled shells left out will soak up moisture and go soft or sticky.

The macaronage test

Macaronage is the folding step, where you knock some air out of the meringue as you combine it with the almond mixture. It’s the most important step and the hardest to describe. Under-mixed batter gives lumpy, cracked tops. Over-mixed batter spreads flat with no feet.

Fold, then test often:

  1. Lift the spatula. The batter should fall off in a thick, unbroken ribbon, like slow lava, not in clumps.
  2. Draw a figure 8. You should be able to draw an “8” with the falling ribbon without it breaking.
  3. Watch it settle. The ribbon should sink back into the surface in roughly 10–20 seconds. If it holds its shape, fold a few more times. If it disappears right away, you’ve gone too far.

Stop a stroke or two early and test again. You can always fold more, but you can’t take folds back.


Still stuck? Bring your questions to a class. We’ll pipe a tray together and look at it side by side, which is the fastest way to learn what “just right” looks like.

← Back to the Journal

Learn it with your hands.

Pipe, bake, fill and decorate a box of twelve with Igor. Beginners welcome.

Book a class